2023 Rookie Class

V9B action board rankings with dynasty career outcomes

36.8%

Starter+ rate

Strong

26.3%

15/57 players

Starter+

36.8%

21/57 players

Usable

49.1%

28/57 players

Miss

50.9%

29/57 players

Outcomes by Pick Band

Band	N	Strong	Starter+	Usable
1-12	12	67%	83%	92%
13-24	12	25%	50%	50%
25-36	11	9%	9%	27%
37-48	12	17%	25%	50%
49+	10	10%	10%	20%

Pick	Player	Pos	Score	Strong%	Starter%	Outcome	Best Pts	Best Finish
1.01	C.J. StroudHOU	QB	96.9	73.8%	82.0%	Strong	281	#11 (2023)
1.02	Jordan AddisonMIN	WR	93.6	73.1%	80.0%	Strong	186	#20 (2023)
1.03	Bijan RobinsonATL	RB	92.8	75.0%	83.9%	Strong	331	#3 (2025)
1.04	Zay FlowersBAL	WR	92.6	73.1%	80.0%	Strong	200	#7 (2025)
1.05	Dalton KincaidBUF	TE	87.6	66.3%	69.9%	Strong	114	#12 (2023)
1.06	Michael MayerLV	TE	85.0	66.3%	69.9%	Miss	58	#33 (2023)
1.07	Bryce YoungCAR	QB	84.2	63.2%	68.0%	Usable	229	#19 (2025)
1.08	Jaxon Smith-NjigbaSEA	WR	80.1	70.7%	76.8%	Strong	300	#2 (2025)
1.09	Quentin JohnstonLAC	WR	78.7	57.0%	65.1%	Starter+	147	#31 (2024)
1.10	Jahmyr GibbsDET	RB	76.8	66.2%	78.4%	Strong	337	#2 (2024)
1.11	Zach CharbonnetSEA	RB	74.8	66.2%	78.4%	Strong	171	#23 (2025)
1.12	Josh DownsIND	WR	74.7	51.2%	60.2%	Starter+	148	#36 (2024)
2.01	De'Von AchaneMIA	RB	70.0	54.1%	67.3%	Strong	289	#5 (2025)
2.02	Rashee RiceKC	WR	72.0	45.9%	55.3%	Starter+	173	#27 (2023)
2.03	Tyjae SpearsTEN	RB	63.7	37.6%	46.5%	Starter+	128	#35 (2023)
2.04	Marvin Mims Jr.DEN	WR	69.6	37.1%	44.3%	Miss	110	#55 (2024)
2.05	Kendre MillerNO	RB	61.7	37.6%	46.5%	Miss	38	#71 (2023)
2.06	Jayden ReedGB	WR	64.9	28.4%	37.3%	Strong	185	#23 (2023)
2.07	Hendon HookerDET	QB	74.6	31.1%	43.7%	Miss	3	#67 (2024)
2.08	Jonathan MingoCAR	WR	60.9	28.4%	37.3%	Miss	63	#83 (2023)
2.09	Anthony Richardson Sr.IND	QB	72.8	35.6%	47.6%	Miss	175	#25 (2024)
2.10	Tank BigsbyJAX	RB	63.8	24.1%	34.8%	Starter+	126	#32 (2024)
2.11	Sam LaPortaDET	TE	71.9	36.6%	49.3%	Strong	196	#1 (2023)
2.12	Deuce VaughnDAL	RB	69.8	21.0%	36.3%	Miss	12	#103 (2023)
3.01	Jalin HyattNYG	WR	63.3	10.4%	17.5%	Miss	49	#97 (2023)
3.02	Cedric TillmanCLE	WR	61.4	10.4%	17.5%	Miss	66	#91 (2024)
3.03	Roschon JohnsonCHI	RB	53.5	14.2%	23.2%	Miss	85	#49 (2023)
3.04	Luke SchoonmakerDAL	TE	56.3	18.2%	26.0%	Miss	44	#44 (2024)
3.05	Evan HullIND	RB	41.9	11.5%	23.1%	Miss	6	#117 (2025)
3.06	Will MalloryIND	TE	53.6	14.0%	22.5%	Miss	30	#58 (2023)
3.07	Brenton StrangeJAX	TE	52.0	14.0%	22.5%	Usable	95	#23 (2025)
3.08	Kayshon BoutteNE	WR	47.9	10.9%	22.0%	Usable	108	#47 (2025)
3.09	DeWayne McBrideMIN	RB	59.4	14.2%	23.2%	—	—	—
3.10	Will LevisTEN	QB	45.5	10.5%	21.0%	Miss	132	#30 (2024)
3.11	Chase BrownCIN	RB	51.9	14.2%	23.2%	Strong	248	#8 (2025)
3.12	Luke MusgraveGB	TE	46.1	11.2%	22.4%	Miss	58	#31 (2023)
4.01	Eric GrayNYG	RB	56.2	12.3%	15.8%	Miss	12	#104 (2024)
4.02	Xavier HutchinsonHOU	WR	59.4	10.8%	14.3%	Miss	81	#63 (2025)
4.03	Chris Rodriguez Jr.WAS	RB	54.9	12.3%	15.8%	Usable	91	#45 (2025)
4.04	Dorian Thompson-RobinsonCLE	QB	45.1	9.4%	16.2%	Miss	26	#52 (2023)
4.05	Sean Tuckernan	RB	25.7	9.9%	19.2%	Usable	87	#48 (2025)
4.06	Israel AbanikandaNYJ	RB	50.1	12.6%	19.3%	Miss	13	#99 (2023)
4.07	Puka NacuaLAR	WR	40.7	9.6%	19.9%	Strong	311	#1 (2025)
4.08	Charlie JonesCIN	WR	47.5	9.6%	19.9%	Miss	17	#155 (2023)
4.09	A.T. PerryNO	WR	57.1	11.3%	17.8%	Miss	55	#91 (2023)
4.10	Parker WashingtonJAX	WR	39.1	9.6%	19.9%	Starter+	156	#27 (2025)
4.11	Tucker KraftGB	TE	43.1	9.7%	19.6%	Strong	138	#9 (2024)
4.12	Tank Dellnan	WR	44.0	8.6%	17.7%	Usable	142	#38 (2023)
5.01	Darnell WashingtonPIT	TE	40.6	8.8%	17.8%	Miss	58	#38 (2025)
5.02	Michael WilsonARI	WR	38.3	8.5%	17.2%	Strong	182	#13 (2025)
5.03	Stetson Bennett IVLAR	QB	34.5	9.0%	18.2%	Miss	—	#115 (2025)
5.04	Zach Evansnan	RB	26.5	9.4%	18.8%	Miss	2	#134 (2023)
5.05	Mohamed Ibrahimnan	RB	6.8	9.4%	18.8%	Miss	—	#145 (2023)
5.06	Keaton Mitchellnan	RB	6.5	9.4%	18.8%	Miss	65	#57 (2023)
5.07	Tre TuckerLV	WR	28.8	8.5%	17.2%	Usable	133	#37 (2025)
5.08	Kenny McIntoshSEA	RB	26.2	9.4%	18.8%	Miss	21	#94 (2024)
5.09	Rakim Jarrettnan	WR	3.9	8.5%	17.2%	Miss	17	#141 (2024)
5.10	Trey Palmernan	WR	5.0	8.5%	17.2%	Miss	76	#72 (2023)